Reviews, Truths and Extortion

As self published authors, we have to do everything ourselves. We have to find people that would be willing to edit our book (for free most of the time). We have to find a cover artist that is willing to work with us for a reasonable price. We also have to find someone to format for us if we don’t get how to do it ourselves. To get our name out there, we recruit people to review our books and help get our ratings up on sites like Goodreads and Amazon. Most people I know are more than glad to accept a free book when all that’s asked of them in return is for them to review a book. Hell, I love doing stuff like that. The last thing we would expect is for someone to accept our free book only to turn around and try to extort us for them to give us a 5 star review.

I recently learned that this happened to a new author. The reviewer messaged the author claiming that their book was full of typos and for the “low price” of $65 the reviewer would gladly give the book a five star review as well as edit the book again for the author. The author, realizing how unethical it would be to literally pay for a five star review, respectfully declined the reviewer’s offer and went about their day. The author didn’t really think much of it after that. As soon as the reviewer got that response, they posted their review.

The review starts out, nice and honest, but at the end, the reviewer goes to town, saying those magical words that turn off any potential reader. “This book was so rife with typos and wrong words that I was repeatedly distracted and taken out of the story.” Now, I am all for an honest review, and I strongly advocate them (as you all have seen), I am not okay with bully reviewers trying to extort authors for a 5 star review. The most fucked up part is that the reviewer still gave the book 4 stars. I have never seen a book get something as high as a 4 star then get thoroughly trashed in the review.

There are books out there that have reviews like this, but they have 1 or 2 stars attached to them. While I have been asked to withhold the most damning piece of evidence, I will tell you this: I have read the book and I completely disagree. If that person were being honest, then like I said, no problem. I just can’t take that review seriously after the original exchange. Let’s be real here for a moment. If you had issues with a book’s editing and wanted to give an honest review, would you go to the author and say “I’ll over look it if you pay me?” I would hope that the answer is no. Hell, I’ve reviewed a book that was full of typos and I was being completely honest, but I didn’t rate that book 4 stars, I rated it 1, as it deserved.  I will leave it at that, and hope that people who come across this book will take the review for what it is.

I just don’t understand why people would behave in such a manner. It’s… Well, it’s disgusting.

What do you guys think? What would you do if a person purposely rated your book lower simply because they wanted money?

About Maegan Provan

I am an indie author and proud of it. I try to update as much as humanly possible, but I'm a busy bee.

Posted on March 31, 2013, in Random Stuff and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. How bizarre! Yet another thing for indies to have to watch out for. How does an author react to this? It’s unethical to pay for a review, and if a reviewer is offering a 5 star review in exchange for money (even if ‘editing’ services are involved), it’s just like using one of those review services that promise to give you a certain amount of good reviews for a fee.

  2. I recently had a client who refused to pay full price for his cover. He paid half and when I refused to send him the cover he sent me a pile of email threats, including saying he would leave one star reviews on my books. I told him to go ahead. With his email as proof I could have the reviews taken down as malicious attack reviews, LOL! In the end I did reimburse him the half-fee, for other reasons, but I thought that took the cake. Sounds like this author ran into an even bigger scammer, though!

  3. I do not know if it’s just me or if perhaps everyone else experiencing issues with your website. It looks like some of the text in your content are running off the screen. Can someone else please provide feedback and let me know if this is happening to them too? This might be a problem with my web browser because I’ve had this happen previously. Cheers

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Crossroads Holistic

A Place to Stop Along Your Path That You Can Call Home

Parenting PTSD

Parenting Children with PTSD


See: Beautiful, Elegant, Bold

Three Quarters & Counting

Everyday activities of blogger who (age wise) is "three quarters and counting."

Silver RavenWolf

Author Blog

Bette A. Stevens, Maine Author

A writer inspired by nature and human nature

Sue Vincent's Daily Echo

Echoes of Life, Love and Laughter

A Narcissist Writes Letters, To Himself

A Hopefully Formerly Depressed Human Vows To Practice Self-Approval

Chris The Story Reading Ape's Blog


Jane Dougherty Writes

About fantastical places and other stuff

Blogging from your phone has never been so...full of typos?

Jordan's Croft

K. A. Jordan - Crofter & Novelist


My interviews with many authors

Amaranthine by Joleene Naylor

The world of the Amaranthine vampire series by Joleene Naylor

A Writer's Life For Me.

Blog of Author Mishka Jenkins


C.N. Lesley writes fantasy and science fiction books

E. J. Rycer

Follow an aspiring author on her literary journey!


Crescent Bound and More

patrick o'scheen

Patrick O'Scheen --author


Pre-publishing Services for eBooks and Print Publications


Author, Dragon Lover, Hopeless Dreamer

Espen Stenersrød- From Pen To Heart

Jack Kerouac with a scent of Henry Vaughn

Darker Passions

Reviews and more of PNR, UF, and darker things.

Random Musings of a Pseudo-Madman, Version 2.0

The sometimes insightful, but many times inane observations of a self-proclaimed Sh*thead living on one side of the proverbial wormhole of existence.

Jennifer's Blog

Just another weblog

Kanundra's Blog

Writing and life. Life and writing.

Writers with Vision

Author promotion blogsite

Shaven Wookiee



This site is the bee's knees

Wendy Nystrom

Life As A Published Author

Anna Kristell Romance

The Diva of Happily Ever After

Sophie E Tallis - Author/Illustrator

Home of the Mistress of Wolves: writing, publishing, fantasy, epic storytelling, art, illustration, poetry, creativity and everything in between!

Lisa V. Proulx, Author/Speaker

Official Website of Author Lisa V. Proulx

The Breezy Writer

This site is Winding down enjoy the free content while you can


Where does magic begin...and end?


The way revenge is best served; the way a war was fought; the way a story should be told. ©

Prescription For Murder


...And Everything in Between...

Welcome to the world of my Life, my Writing and Everything in Between...

Writings Of Miss Madison

Books thoughts and more

Allison Cosgrove

Author of Murder, Mayhem and Romance

Poetic Parfait

Good poetry is like a dessert you just can't put down

Suddenly they all died. The end.

Write or write not - there is no aspiring.


The online presence of dark fiction writer C.M. Saunders

%d bloggers like this: